Limit from the Left
Limit from Below
A one-sided limit which, in the example x→0−limx1=−∞,
restricts x such that x < 0.
In general, a limit
from the left restricts the domain variable to values less than
the number the domain variable approaches. When a limit is taken
from the left it is written x→a−limf(x) or x↑alimf(x).
For
example, x→0−limx1=−∞ since x1 tends
toward –∞ as x gets
closer and closer to 0 from the left.
Formal Definitions:
1. x→a−limf(x)=L if and only if for each ε>0 there exists a δ>0 such that
a−δ<x<a⇒∣f(x)−L∣<ε.
2. x→a−limf(x)=∞ if and only if for each N there exists a δ>0 such that
a−δ<x<a⇒f(x)>N.
3. x→a−limf(x)=−∞ if and only if for each N there exists a δ>0 such that
a−δ<x<a⇒f(x)<N.
See
also
Limit from the right, infinity
Worked Example
Problem: Find the limit from the left of f(x) = 1/x as x approaches 0.
Step 1: Write the limit using left-hand limit notation.
x→0−limx1 Step 2: Choose values of x that are negative and getting closer to 0: x = −1, −0.1, −0.01, −0.001.
f(−1)=−1,f(−0.1)=−10,f(−0.01)=−100,f(−0.001)=−1000 Step 3: As x approaches 0 from the left, the outputs become increasingly large in the negative direction.
x1→−∞ as x→0− Step 4: State the result. The function does not approach a finite number; it decreases without bound.
x→0−limx1=−∞ Answer: The limit from the left of 1/x as x approaches 0 is −∞. Another Example
This example uses a piecewise function to show how the left-hand limit selects only the piece defined for x < c, and demonstrates a case where the left and right limits disagree.
Problem: Find the limit from the left of the piecewise function g(x) as x approaches 2, where g(x) = x + 3 for x < 2 and g(x) = 10 − x for x ≥ 2.
Step 1: Write the left-hand limit. Since we approach 2 from the left, we only use x < 2.
x→2−limg(x) Step 2: For x < 2, the rule is g(x) = x + 3. Substitute values approaching 2 from below: x = 1.9, 1.99, 1.999.
g(1.9)=4.9,g(1.99)=4.99,g(1.999)=4.999 Step 3: The outputs approach 5. You can also substitute directly into x + 3.
x→2−lim(x+3)=2+3=5 Step 4: Note that the limit from the right would use the other piece: g(x) = 10 − x gives 10 − 2 = 8. The left-hand and right-hand limits differ, so the two-sided limit does not exist at x = 2.
x→2−limg(x)=5=8=x→2+limg(x) Answer: The limit from the left is 5. Because this does not equal the limit from the right (which is 8), the two-sided limit at x = 2 does not exist.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a limit from the left and a limit from the right?
A limit from the left (x→c−) considers only x-values less than c, while a limit from the right (x→c+) considers only x-values greater than c. If both one-sided limits exist and are equal, the two-sided limit exists and equals that common value. If they differ, the two-sided limit does not exist. When do you need to use a left-hand limit?
You use left-hand limits when analyzing piecewise functions at the boundary between pieces, when a function is only defined on one side of a point, or when determining whether a two-sided limit exists. They also arise when studying continuity: a function is continuous at c only if both one-sided limits equal f(c).
What does the minus sign in the superscript mean?
The superscript minus in c− does not mean a negative number. It is notation indicating that x approaches c from values that are less than c — that is, from the left side on the number line. Similarly, c+ means x approaches c from values greater than c.
Limit from the Left vs. Limit from the Right
| Limit from the Left | Limit from the Right |
|---|
| Notation | limx→c−f(x) | limx→c+f(x) |
| Direction of approach | x approaches c through values less than c | x approaches c through values greater than c |
| Also called | Left-hand limit, limit from below | Right-hand limit, limit from above |
| Piecewise functions | Uses the piece defined for x < c | Uses the piece defined for x > c |
| Relationship to two-sided limit | Must equal the right-hand limit for the two-sided limit to exist | Must equal the left-hand limit for the two-sided limit to exist |
Why It Matters
Left-hand limits appear throughout calculus whenever you check continuity at a point or analyze piecewise-defined functions, which model real situations like tax brackets or shipping rates. They are essential for understanding the formal definition of a limit: the two-sided limit exists only when the left-hand and right-hand limits both exist and are equal. Mastering one-sided limits is also a prerequisite for topics like derivatives, improper integrals, and the behavior of functions near vertical asymptotes.
Common Mistakes
Mistake: Confusing the superscript minus with a negative sign and thinking x→0− means x approaches −0 or a negative number. Correction: The superscript − is directional notation meaning 'from below.' When you see x→0−, it means x takes values like −0.1, −0.01, −0.001 — values slightly less than 0, not that x is heading toward some other number. Mistake: Using the wrong piece of a piecewise function when computing the left-hand limit.
Correction: For limx→c−f(x), always use the rule that applies when x<c, even if the function is defined differently at x=c itself. The value f(c) does not matter for the limit.