Voting Method — Definition & Example
A voting method is a rule for deciding who wins an election from the voters' ballots. Different methods can pick different winners from the same set of ballots.
Given a set of candidates and a preference profile, which lists each voter's ranking of the candidates, a voting method (also called a social choice function) is a rule that assigns every possible profile a winner or a set of tied winners. Common examples are plurality (most first-place votes), the Borda count (points by rank position), and instant runoff (repeatedly eliminate the candidate with the fewest first-place votes until someone holds a majority).
Worked Example
Problem: A club of 20 members ranks three candidates, A, B and C. Eight ballots read A > C > B, seven read B > C > A, and five read C > B > A. Find the winner under plurality, instant runoff and the Borda count, using the same set of ballots each time.
Step 1: Plurality: count only first choices. A has the most, so A wins, even though 8 of 20 is not a majority.
Step 2: Instant runoff: a majority requires 11 votes, and no one has that. Eliminate C, who has the fewest first-place votes. C's 5 ballots list B next, so they transfer to B.
Step 3: Borda count: a first choice earns 2 points, a second choice 1 point, and a last choice 0 points. As a check, the totals add to points.
Answer: Plurality elects A, instant runoff elects B, and the Borda count elects C. The ballots stay the same, so the method alone decides the outcome.
Why It Matters
C is also the Condorcet winner here. C beats A 12 to 8 and beats B 13 to 7 in head-to-head matchups, yet plurality ranks C last. Arrow's impossibility theorem shows that, with three or more candidates, no ranked voting method can satisfy a short list of fairness conditions (unanimity, independence of irrelevant alternatives, no dictator) for every possible set of ballots. That result sits at the center of social choice theory, a field that connects discrete math, economics and political science. It also shapes real decisions, such as cities adopting ranked-choice voting.
Common Mistakes
Mistake: Treating the plurality leader as the candidate a majority prefers.
Correction: A plurality winner may have only a minority of first-place votes. Here A leads with 8 of 20 votes, but 12 voters rank A last. Check for a majority before you claim one.
