Weighted Voting — Definition, Formula & Example
Weighted voting is a voting system in which some voters' votes count more than others, so a motion passes when the total weight of the yes votes reaches a set threshold called the quota.
A weighted voting system is written , where players have positive weights and is the quota. A set of players (a coalition) is winning when the sum of its weights is at least . For decisions to be well defined, the quota usually satisfies , where is the sum of all the weights. A player is critical in a winning coalition if the coalition stops winning when that player leaves.
Key Formula
Where:
- = a coalition, meaning any group of players voting together
- = the weight (number of votes) of player
- = the quota, the minimum total weight needed to pass a motion
- = the total weight of all players,
Worked Example
Problem: Three shareholders vote under the system . Player has 4 votes, has 3, and has 2. Find each player's Banzhaf power index.
Step 1: Find the winning coalitions, meaning those with total weight at least 6. The coalition has only 5 votes, so it loses. The single players have at most 4 votes, so they lose as well.
Step 2: Mark the critical players. In each two-player coalition, both players are critical. In the full coalition, only is critical. Without the total drops to , but without it is still , and without it is still .
Step 3: Divide each player's critical count by the total number of critical instances.
Answer: The Banzhaf power indices are : (60%), : (20%), and : (20%). and have equal power even though their weights differ.
Why It Matters
Weighted voting models real bodies such as shareholder meetings and the U.S. Electoral College. The Council of the European Union formerly used weighted votes before moving to double-majority voting in 2014. In 1965, John Banzhaf used power-index analysis to show that one county board's weighted voting system gave some members no real power. It is a standard topic in the voting-theory unit of liberal-arts math and discrete math courses.
Common Mistakes
Mistake: Assuming a player's power is proportional to their weight.
Correction: Power depends on how often a player is critical, not on raw vote count. In , has more votes than , yet both have a power index of . Count the critical players in the winning coalitions instead of comparing weights.
