Mathwords logoMathwords

Regiomontanus' Angle Maximization Problem — Formula & Example

Regiomontanus' angle maximization problem asks where you should stand so that a picture or screen hanging above your eye level fills the largest possible angle of your view. Standing too close or too far both make that angle smaller, so the best spot lies somewhere in between.

Let the bottom and top edges of an object lie at heights aa and bb (0<a<b0 < a < b) above the horizontal line through the observer's eye. Let x>0x > 0 be the observer's horizontal distance from the wall. The viewing angle is θ(x)=arctan⁡bx−arctan⁡ax\theta(x) = \arctan\frac{b}{x} - \arctan\frac{a}{x}. The problem is to find the xx that maximizes θ\theta. The unique maximizer is x=abx = \sqrt{ab}. Geometrically, this is the point where a circle through the two edges is tangent to the eye-level line. The power-of-a-point theorem then gives x2=abx^2 = ab. The German astronomer Regiomontanus posed the problem in 1471, and it is often cited as the first new extreme-value problem posed since antiquity.

Key Formula

x∗=ab,tan⁡θmax⁡=b−a2abx^{*} = \sqrt{ab}, \qquad \tan\theta_{\max} = \frac{b-a}{2\sqrt{ab}}
Where:
  • x∗x^{*} = Horizontal distance from the wall that gives the largest viewing angle
  • aa = Height of the object's bottom edge above your eye level
  • bb = Height of the object's top edge above your eye level
  • θmax⁡\theta_{\max} = The largest possible viewing angle

Worked Example

Problem: A movie screen's bottom edge is 4 ft above your eye level, and its top edge is 9 ft above your eye level. How far from the wall should you sit to get the largest viewing angle, and what is that angle?
Step 1: Write the viewing angle as the difference of two angles measured from eye level. Let xx be your distance from the wall in feet.
θ(x)=arctan⁡9x−arctan⁡4x\theta(x) = \arctan\frac{9}{x} - \arctan\frac{4}{x}
Step 2: Differentiate and set the derivative equal to 0. Cross-multiplying gives 4(x2+81)=9(x2+16)4(x^2+81) = 9(x^2+16), so 5x2=1805x^2 = 180 and x=6x = 6, since a distance must be positive. The derivative is positive for x<6x < 6 and negative for x>6x > 6, so x=6x = 6 gives a maximum.
θ′(x)=−9x2+81+4x2+16=0  ⇒  x=6\theta'(x) = -\frac{9}{x^2+81} + \frac{4}{x^2+16} = 0 \;\Rightarrow\; x = 6
Step 3: Find the maximum angle. Use the tangent subtraction formula with x=6x = 6.
tan⁡θ=96−461+96⋅46=5/62=512\tan\theta = \frac{\frac{9}{6} - \frac{4}{6}}{1 + \frac{9}{6}\cdot\frac{4}{6}} = \frac{5/6}{2} = \frac{5}{12}
Answer: Sit 6 ft from the wall. This matches 4⋅9=6\sqrt{4 \cdot 9} = 6. The largest viewing angle is arctan⁡512≈22.6∘\arctan\frac{5}{12} \approx 22.6^\circ.

Why It Matters

The same setup tells a soccer player where to shoot from along a line to see the widest goal angle. It also helps designers place seating in theaters and museums. In AP Calculus, it is a standard optimization problem that combines inverse trig derivatives with the first derivative test.

Common Mistakes

Mistake: Measuring the heights of the object from the floor instead of from your eye level.
Correction: The angles are measured from the horizontal line through your eye. Subtract your eye height from each edge height first. For example, edges at 9 ft and 14 ft above the floor become a=4a = 4 and b=9b = 9 for a 5 ft eye height.

Related Terms