Misuse of Statistics — Definition & Example
Misuse of statistics is when data are presented or interpreted so they give a false impression. The numbers themselves can be accurate while the conclusion they suggest is wrong.
A misuse of statistics is any method of collecting, summarizing, displaying, or interpreting data that supports a conclusion the data do not justify. Common types include biased or unrepresentative sampling, selective reporting (cherry-picking), graphs with distorted or truncated scales, comparing raw counts when proportions are needed, and inferring causation from correlation.
How It Works
Watch for these common tricks. A truncated axis exaggerates small differences, as in the example below. A biased sample, such as an online poll answered only by a show's own fans, overrepresents one group, so its results do not describe the whole population. Cherry-picking reports only the time period, subgroup, or study that supports a claim and leaves out the rest. Raw counts mislead when groups differ in size: a big city can have more car accidents than a small town and still have a lower rate per 1,000 drivers. Correlation is not causation: ice cream sales and drownings rise together because hot weather drives both, not because one causes the other.
Worked Example
Problem: A bar graph compares bike sales. Store A sold 50 bikes and Store B sold 55 bikes. The vertical axis starts at 45 instead of 0. How much more did Store B actually sell, and how much more does it appear to sell on the graph?
Step 1: Find the actual percent increase from Store A to Store B.
Step 2: Find the visible bar heights. The axis starts at 45, so each bar shows only the part above 45. Then compare the two heights.
Step 3: Store B's bar is twice as tall as Store A's bar. On the graph, Store B appears to sell 100% more.
Answer: Store B actually sold 10% more bikes, but the truncated axis makes it look like 100% more. Starting the axis at 0 would show the true comparison.
Why It Matters
In AP Statistics, free-response questions often ask you to spot bias in a survey or to explain why a study cannot show cause and effect. Advertising claims and news charts use the same tricks, so this skill helps you judge evidence outside the classroom.
Common Mistakes
Mistake: Assuming a statistic is trustworthy as long as the numbers are correct.
Correction: Accurate numbers can still mislead. Check how the sample was chosen, where each axis starts, whether counts should be proportions, and whether a cause is being claimed from a correlation.
