Mathwords logoMathwords

Knaster Inheritance Procedure — Definition, Formula & Example

The Knaster Inheritance Procedure is a way to split an inheritance fairly. Each heir bids secretly on each item, the highest bidder gets the item, and cash payments balance things out so every heir receives at least a fair share by their own valuation.

Given nn heirs and items k=1,…,mk = 1, \dots, m, heir ii submits a sealed bid bi,kb_{i,k} for each item. Each item goes to a highest bidder. Heir ii's fair share is Fi=1n∑kbi,kF_i = \frac{1}{n}\sum_k b_{i,k}. Heir ii pays the estate (value of items won, measured by heir ii's own bids) − Fi-\,F_i. A negative amount means the estate pays heir ii. The leftover surplus SS is then divided equally, so each heir ends with value Fi+SnF_i + \frac{S}{n}. The method is attributed to the Polish mathematician Bronisław Knaster (1940s). It assumes item values add up and that heirs have enough cash to make payments.

Key Formula

Fi=1n∑k=1mbi,k,S=∑k=1mmax⁡ibi,k−∑i=1nFiF_i = \frac{1}{n}\sum_{k=1}^{m} b_{i,k}, \qquad S = \sum_{k=1}^{m} \max_i b_{i,k} - \sum_{i=1}^{n} F_i
Where:
  • FiF_i = fair share of heir i, based only on heir i's own bids
  • bi,kb_{i,k} = heir i's sealed bid on item k
  • nn = number of heirs
  • mm = number of items
  • SS = surplus left after the first settlement, split equally among all n heirs

Worked Example

Problem: Three heirs, A, B, and C, inherit a house. Their sealed bids are A: $300,000, B: $240,000, C: $270,000. Use the Knaster procedure to divide the estate.
Step 1: Find each heir's fair share by dividing that heir's bid by 3.
FA=300,0003=100,000,FB=80,000,FC=90,000F_A = \frac{300{,}000}{3} = 100{,}000,\quad F_B = 80{,}000,\quad F_C = 90{,}000
Step 2: A bid highest, so A gets the house. A pays the estate the house's value minus A's fair share. The estate pays B and C their fair shares.
300,000−100,000=200,000300{,}000 - 100{,}000 = 200{,}000
Step 3: Find the surplus left in the estate and split it equally among the three heirs.
S=200,000−80,000−90,000=30,000,30,0003=10,000S = 200{,}000 - 80{,}000 - 90{,}000 = 30{,}000, \qquad \frac{30{,}000}{3} = 10{,}000
Answer: A gets the house and pays a net $190,000. B receives $90,000 and C receives $100,000. Each heir ends up $10,000 above their own fair share.

Why It Matters

Knaster's method, often called the method of sealed bids, appears in the fair-division chapter of many liberal-arts math textbooks, alongside the lone-divider and last-diminisher methods. Mediators use the same sealed-bid idea when they split estates or business assets that cannot be cut into pieces.

Common Mistakes

Mistake: Computing every heir's fair share from the winning bid, for example giving B one-third of $300,000.
Correction: Each heir's fair share comes from that heir's own bids. B valued the house at $240,000, so B's fair share is $80,000.

Related Terms